Pitched Unfairly

The Enterprise of the Indies

Reach the East by sailing west.

A seed round for the Crowns of Castile and Aragon.

Santa Fe · Spring 1492

The problem

Every peppercorn pays three middlemen.

Since Constantinople fell in 1453, the road east runs through other people's ports.

  1. The IndiesPepper, cloves, cinnamon, nutmeg
  2. Arab merchant fleetsCarry it across the Indian Ocean Takes a cut
  3. Ottoman and Mamluk portsConstantinople, Alexandria, Beirut Takes a cut
  4. VeniceHolds the Mediterranean resale Takes a cut
  5. Your kitchen in CastilePays for every hand it passed through

The solution

The world is round. Sail west to get east.

No Sultan, no Venice, no tolls. One stretch of open sea.

  • West: open sea, zero tolls
  • East: overland, three tolls
Chart drawn to our own scale

Why now

Granada fell in January. The Crown is free.

  1. 1453 Constantinople falls

    The Ottomans take the gate to the eastern trade.

  2. 1488 Dias rounds the Cape

    Portugal finds the bottom of Africa. India is next.

  3. Jan 1492 Granada surrenders

    Ten years of war are over. Your treasury is free.

Market

The market is the entire East.

Sized by Marco Polo, who has actually been there.

All of AsiaEvery spice, silk and pearl east of the Sultan
The IndiesSpices, plus Cipangu’s gold roofs, per Polo
1 Great KhanLetter of introduction: signed

The math

On our math, Japan is 2,400 miles west.

Size of the Earth
75%
Canaries to Japan
2,400 nmi
In the way
Open sea

Traction

Eight years of pitching. Zero miles sailed.

0nautical miles west, to date

Conviction Total

  1. 1484Lisbon John II of PortugalHis experts: the distance is far too short. Passed
  2. 1486 to 1490Castile The Talavera commissionGrossly underestimated. Recommended no. Passed
  3. 1488Lisbon John II, againThen Dias sails home from the Cape. No. Passed
  4. Around 1489London Henry VII, via BartholomewNo deal. Passed
  5. January 1492Santa Fe Ferdinand and IsabellaNo. Then a royal guard, two leagues down the road. Recalled

Team

Two Pinzóns, a shipowner, and the Khan’s translator.

  • CC Christopher Columbus Founder and Admiral (pending)

    Genoese. Years on Portuguese ships, as far as the Gold Coast.

  • MP Martín Alonso Pinzón Captain, Pinta

    The best-known captain in Palos. His name signs the crew.

  • VP Vicente Yáñez Pinzón Captain, Niña

    His younger brother. Same port, same nerve.

  • JC Juan de la Cosa Owner, Santa María

    Brings his own ship. Also draws a very good map.

  • LT Luis de Torres Interpreter

    Hebrew, Aramaic and some Arabic. For the Great Khan.

Competition

Portugal is going around Africa. We go straight there.

Portugal
Decades down the coast. Reached the Cape in 1488. India: not yet.
Castile
One stop in the Canaries. Then due west.

Roadmap

Seventy days from Palos to the Indies.

Day 70 12 Oct

Land, 2 a.m. Founder confirms he saw it first.

  1. 3 Aug Sail from Palos at dawn.
  2. 6 Aug Pinta's rudder comes loose. Fix it in the Canaries.
  3. 6 Sep Leave La Gomera. Last land on the chart.
  4. 9 Sep Start a second logbook, with smaller numbers, for morale.
  5. 16 Sep Weed everywhere. Land is surely close.
  6. 7 Oct Follow the birds southwest.
  7. 10 Oct Morale event. Ask the crew for three more days.
  8. 12 Oct Land, 2 a.m. Founder confirms he saw it first.

Risks we've considered

We've thought of everything.

  • Sailing off the edge Not a risk. The Earth is round; everyone in this room knows it.
  • The crew loses its nerve Two logbooks. The crew sees the smaller numbers.
  • Water and supplies Last resupply in the Canaries, Castile's own islands.
  • A Portuguese claim The Treaty of Alcáçovas leaves us the Canaries. We sail west of Africa, not down it.
  • The committee says the ocean is too wide Respectfully, we have done our own math.
  • A continent in the way Not considered

The ask

Three ships. A tenth of everything.

  • Admiral of the Ocean SeaHereditary
  • Viceroy and GovernorOf every land found
  • 10% of the profitsTax free, forever

Ofeverythingfound

The Crown
90% of the profits, and the lands
Columbus
10%, tax free, forever. Plus the titles.
Town of Palos
Nothing. It was a fine.